October 6, 2024

Neil Murray believes a new focus should be established before choosing Michael Beale’s replacement.

Philippe Clement has never worked on a project without one. Kevin Muscat learned his trade as a coach under a man who proved at Celtic that he didn’t need one. Former Rangers star Neil Murray can’t believe his old club still doesn’t have one.

Rangers have had a checkered record when it comes to football directors throughout the years. But Murray, a former chief scout and head of recruitment at Ibrox as well as a four-time league champion under Walter Smith, fears his old club will put the cart before the horse if they move forward with plans to replace Michael Beale without first finding someone to take over Ross Wilson’s responsibilities.

It has now been six months since the Ibrox board permitted sporting director Wilson to leave the rising fan rage directed at him after another title chase fell through due to a failed recruitment drive. The move placed Michael Beale in charge of the club’s finances, but with no one above him to keep an eye on how he spent the money, it proved to be another terrible blunder for both the club and the Londoner.

Rangers are on the search for their third manager in less than two years, with Celtic once again leading the way. However, Murray believes that the search for Beale’s replacement on the bottom floor should have begun after they had first installed someone upstairs.

Neil Murray left days after the club launched investigation

“I’ve got to be honest, I’m amazed that Ross Wilson wasn’t replaced,” said the 50-year-old hero of Gers’ nine-in-a-row period, who now works as an agent and for a sports data analysis firm. It’s odd to me.

“If you give a manager the keys to the castle and carte blanche to bring in players then it’s often a high-risk strategy. In Michael Beale’s case, it hasn’t paid off and the club are now two months into a season and expecting a new manager to come in and work with players he might not necessarily want.

“I know that can happen in a system where you have a director of football but at least in that way the players signed is down to a club decision rather than one individual manager’s. The new manager may or may not want to work with a director of football and that’s what this interview process will allow Rangers to find out.”

On this week’s edition of the Record Rangers Podcast, Belgian journalist Ludo Vandewalle warned that if the Ibrox board decides to put their trust in former Genk, Club Brugge, and Monaco coach Clement, they will be trusting a man who has never had to worry about recruitment because he always had someone else to do the hard yards when it came to sniffing out fresh faces.

Ange Postecoglou, on the other hand, didn’t mind not having someone hovering over him at Celtic Park, using his expertise of the Japanese league to bring over the best the J-League had to offer as he changed a dysfunctional Hoops squad in the space of one window.

“But a part of that modern-day approach is a sporting director as every club has got one. OK, people will point to Celtic and say they don’t have one. But you could say Ange Postecolou was a director of football in his own right given the knowledge he had of the Japanese market. “That worked for Celtic but if you’re copying blueprints for modern-day football structures then the vast majority have a sporting director. Rangers are a big club with big departments and in terms of a football figurehead, it’s a role that’s important. “And it’s important for the board too because a sporting director acts as a buffer between them and the coaching staff. It takes away a lot of the pressure from the board and puts it on the director of football.”

But Murray believes Rangers will strike gold if they can find a manager who can equal the new Tottenham manager’s signing strike rate. “I’ve read that the Rangers are moving toward a more data-driven model with their scouting to become more in line with a modern approach,” he remarked.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *